How to Actually Get Your Crew to Use Your EAP (Because Right Now They Won't Touch It)
You signed up for an EAP. Added it to your benefits package. Maybe even mentioned it at a crew meeting.
Nobody's using it.
Let me guess why.
- •Your crew thinks EAPs are for "people with problems," not for construction workers who pride themselves on toughness.
- •They don't know what an EAP even is or what it covers.
- •They're worried it's not actually confidential and management will find out.
- •Or they tried to use it once, couldn't figure out how to access it from a job site, and gave up.
Sound familiar?
Here's the reality: EAP utilization in construction is under 2% industry-wide. You're paying for a benefit that 98% of your people will never touch, which means you're getting zero value from one of the most potentially impactful benefits you offer.
But here's the good news: This is fixable. You just need to stop implementing EAPs like they're corporate wellness programs and start treating them like the critical job site resource they should be.
Why Construction Crews Don't Use EAPs (Even When They Need Them)
Before we fix it, let's understand what's broken:
They Don't Know It Exists
You mentioned it once during onboarding. It's buried on page 47 of the benefits booklet. There's no visible reminder. Most of your crew has no idea they even have access to mental health support.
They Don't Trust It's Confidential
Construction culture runs on reputation. Nobody wants to be the guy who "couldn't hack it" or "needed help." If they think management can see who's using the EAP, they won't touch it. Period.
The Access Points Don't Work for Construction Workers
Your EAP portal requires a company email address (most of your crew doesn't have one). The phone line is only open during business hours (when they're on site). The video counselling requires privacy and wifi (which job sites don't have). Every access barrier is a reason not to bother.
Construction Mental Health Stigma is Real
Despite suicide rates in construction being 4x higher than average, talking about mental health is still seen as weakness. Your guys are more likely to show up injured than admit they're struggling with anxiety, depression, or burnout.
They Don't Understand What It Actually Covers
"EAP" means nothing to most people. Does it help with stress? Financial problems? Family issues? Substance use? Chronic pain? If they don't know what problems the EAP can solve, they won't connect their struggles to the resource.
How to Actually Fix This
Alright, enough diagnosing the problem. Here's how to get your crew to actually use the mental health support you're already paying for:
Make It Visible Everywhere
Your EAP provider should give you materials. Actually use them.
If your guys can't remember the EAP phone number when they need it at 2am on a Sunday, your visibility strategy failed.
Normalize It Through Leadership
Your foremen and site supervisors set the tone. If they treat mental health like a joke, your crew will too.
Training for supervisors should cover:
Real talk: If your leadership team won't engage with this, your crew won't either. Period.
Simplify Access to One Phone Number
Forget portals, apps, and multi-step processes. Your crew needs ONE phone number that works 24/7, where a real person answers, and they can access help immediately.
That number should be:
When I review EAPs with clients, the first question I ask is "Can your electrician call this number from his truck at midnight and get help?" If the answer is no, we're fixing that.
Address the Confidentiality Fear Head-On
In every single communication about the EAP, reinforce: "Management never knows who calls. Ever."
Explain how confidentiality actually works:
The more you address this fear directly, the more trust you build.
Show Real Examples of What the EAP Covers
Stop saying "mental health support" - that's vague. Start giving concrete examples:
"The EAP can help if you're dealing with:"
Give your crew permission to have problems and show them the EAP solves real things they're actually dealing with.
Do Quarterly Mental Health Tool Box Talks
You do safety talks. Do mental health talks too.
15 minutes, every quarter:
Make mental health support as routine as discussing lockout/tagout procedures.
Track Utilization and Actually Improve
Ask your benefits provider for quarterly utilization reports. If you're under 10%, you have work to do.
Survey your crew (anonymously) to understand barriers:
Then fix the gaps you find.
Choose the Right EAP Provider in the First Place
Not all EAPs are created equal, especially for construction.
You need providers that offer:
(I break down the top 5 providers that actually work for construction in this detailed guide - worth reading if you're choosing or switching providers.)
Real Example: What Good Implementation Looks Like
One of my clients, a 45-person mechanical contractor, was paying for an EAP with 0% utilization for four years. Zero. Nobody had ever called.
We switched providers to one with construction-specific training, then implemented:
First year after implementation:
- • 18% utilization (up from 0%)
- • Eight people accessed counselling
- • Two got substance use support
- • Three used financial counselling during slow season
- • One accessed crisis support and later told the PM it saved his life
Zero lost-time incidents that year. Turnover dropped from 11 people to 2. Morale visibly improved.
Same EAP cost. Completely different outcome.
The Bottom Line
You can't fix your crew's mental health by throwing a benefit at them and hoping they figure it out. Implementation matters more than the actual EAP provider (though both matter).
If your utilization is under 10%, you're wasting money on a benefit that isn't working. But the fix isn't complicated - it's about visibility, access, trust, and culture.
Your crew builds things. They solve problems. They show up when it's hard. The least you can do is make mental health support so visible and accessible that when they need it, there's zero friction between the problem and the help.
Ready to Build an EAP Strategy That Actually Works?
Want to build an EAP strategy that your crew will actually use? Start by reviewing whether your current provider even works for construction workers - here's my breakdown of the top 5 EAP providers in Canada. Then let's talk about implementation that works for your specific crew and culture.
Because paying for benefits nobody uses is a waste. But having the benefit available and making it work? That's how you keep your best people, prevent crises, and run a business that actually gives a damn about the humans who make it all happen.
Written by: Steffen deGraaf
Group Benefits Consultant, AEC Benefits
Steffen specializes in helping construction and trades companies build cost-effective benefits plans that save money while keeping teams protected and valued. With over 20 years of experience in Ontario's construction industry, he understands the unique challenges business owners face.
Related Articles
Complete Guide to Group Benefits for Construction Companies
Everything construction company owners need to know about group benefits: costs, coverage options, common mistakes, cost-saving strategies, and how to choose the right plan for your team. A comprehensive resource hub.
Flexible Coverage: Why it Matters for Construction Teams
Many companies think "same benefits for everyone = fair." But giving your field crew the same plan as your executives isn't fair—it's wasteful. Here's why departmental divisions let you give each role the benefits they actually need, at the same cost.
Why Switching Insurance Companies Is Stupid Simple Now (And What That Means for Your Renewal)
Remember when switching insurance companies felt like moving job sites mid-project? That's done. Modern insurers have made onboarding so easy that switching is now a no-brainer. Here's what changed and why it matters at renewal time.